The rules of customer loyalty are being rewritten. In a landscape where attention is the new currency, web3 is emerging as the game-changer that puts power back into the hands of consumers. Enter the realm of new loyalty programs—where every interaction is an opportunity, every token holds potential, and every customer becomes a stakeholder.

Article originally prepared in Italian for my personal podcast Disruptive Talks (read it here, in italian).
This content is also available as a self produced video documentary, here, and in audio podcast, available here.

Imagine a world where 7-Eleven, Walmart or Esselunga membership isn’t just a plastic card in your wallet or points on a mobile app. Picture a reality where every coffee you buy, every mile you fly, every hotel night you book doesn’t just earn you rewards—it makes you a genuine stakeholder in the brand’s success and story.

This is happening right now, principally guided by web3 and blockchain technology. We’re stepping into an time where your brand interactions are as unique and valuable as the NFTs they might earn you. Where your data isn’t just a number in a company’s database, but a digital asset you own and control.

From the corner café to global airlines, businesses are waking up to this new reality. They’re reimagining loyalty programs not as a one-way street of points and perks, but as a vibrant community where customers and brands grow together.

History and limitation of traditional loyalty programs

The concept of customer loyalty programs has a rich history dating back to the late 19th century. The S&H Green Stamps program, introduced in 1896, is often considered the pioneer of modern loyalty schemes. Customers would receive stamps with purchases, which could be redeemed for merchandise from S&H catalogs. This model laid the groundwork for future loyalty initiatives.

The 1980s saw a significant evolution with the introduction of airline frequent flyer programs. American Airlines’ AAdvantage program, launched in 1981, revolutionized the industry by offering miles as a reward for flights, which could be redeemed for free travel. This concept quickly spread to other airlines and industries, becoming a standard practice in customer retention strategies.

With the increase in options available to consumers and the decrease in their attention span, the need for true loyalty is more pressing than ever. Without focused attention on transformative technologies, new mental models, and strategies that drive social change, the duration and effectiveness of traditional loyalty programs are destined to decline.

Despite their widespread adoption and initial success, traditional loyalty programs have several inherent limitations:

• Transaction-centric approach: these programs primarily focus on incentivizing repeated purchases rather than fostering genuine brand loyalty. This approach often fails to create emotional connections between customers and brands.
• Conditional benefits: the rewards system is typically designed so that benefits are contingent upon continued participation. Customers risk losing accumulated rewards if they discontinue their relationship with the brand, creating a form of artificial loyalty.
• Limited value recognition: traditional programs often fail to acknowledge the full spectrum of value a customer can bring to a brand, such as word-of-mouth marketing or social media influence. They tend to reduce customer worth to mere transaction volumes.
• Lack of personalization: many programs offer generic rewards that may not align with individual customer preferences or needs, missing opportunities for more meaningful engagement.
• Data silos: information collected through these programs is often trapped in organizational silos, preventing a holistic view of customer behavior and preferences.
• Short-term focus: the emphasis on immediate sales often overshadows long-term relationship building and brand advocacy.
• Diminishing returns: as loyalty programs have become ubiquitous, their effectiveness in differentiating brands has decreased, leading to program fatigue among consumers.
• Limited interoperability: traditional programs typically operate within closed ecosystems, restricting the flexibility and value of earned rewards.

In the current market landscape, characterized by an abundance of consumer choices and decreasing attention spans, the need for innovative loyalty strategies is more critical than ever. The limitations of traditional programs highlight the necessity for transformative technologies and new paradigms that can foster authentic, value-driven relationships between brands and customers. Without addressing these fundamental issues, traditional loyalty programs risk becoming obsolete in an increasingly dynamic and digitally-driven marketplace.

Blockchain-powered loyalty: web3’s promise for authentic customer connections

In this context, web3 emerges as an effective alternative. This new iteration of the web fundamentally reshapes how users interact with online platforms, transitioning from a model of centralized control to one of decentralized empowerment. The term “web3” can be defined as a decentralized online ecosystem based on blockchain technology. It aims to empower users with greater control over their data, identity, and digital assets while fostering a more transparent, secure, and interoperable internet experience.

At its core, it replaces conventional login credentials with decentralized wallets secured by private keys, leveraging smart contract, digital assets, and immersive virtual environments to create a more secure, transparent, and user-centric digital ecosystem.

The architecture of Web3 is built on several key technological pillars. Blockchain technology serves as the foundation, providing an immutable and distributed ledger that ensures the integrity and traceability of all transactions. Smart contracts, self-executing code on the blockchain, automate and enforce agreements without intermediaries. Tokenization, the process of representing real-world assets or rights as digital tokens, enables new forms of ownership and value exchange. Decentralized applications (dApps) run on peer-to-peer networks, reducing reliance on centralized servers and enhancing resilience against censorship or single points of failure.

This technological framework offers numerous advantages that address longstanding issues in digital interactions and loyalty programs. Trust is inherently built into the system through cryptographic verification, eliminating the need for third-party intermediaries to validate transactions or manage user data. Transparency is dramatically enhanced, as all actions on the blockchain are visible and auditable by any participant, fostering an environment of unprecedented fairness and accountability.

Data ownership and control are fundamentally redefined: users become the true owners of their personal information, with the ability to selectively share, monetize, or withhold their data as they see fit. This shift in data sovereignty not only empowers individuals but also creates new opportunities for more equitable and consensual data utilization in marketing and customer relationship management.

The concept of digital identity evolves in Web3, moving from siloed, platform-specific profiles to portable, user-controlled identities that can seamlessly interact across various services and applications. This interoperability extends to digital assets and loyalty rewards, allowing users to transfer and utilize their earned benefits across different platforms and ecosystems, dramatically increasing their utility and value.

Web3 also introduces novel economic models through cryptocurrencies and token economies. These systems can incentivize positive behaviors, reward community contributions, and create more aligned interests between platforms and their users. In the context of loyalty programs, this opens up possibilities for more dynamic, engaging, and value-driven reward systems that go beyond traditional point accumulation.

The evolution towards web3 loyalty programs

The transition from traditional to blockchain-based programs represents a shift in customer engagement strategies, leveraging the core principles presented in precedent chapter, in primis Tokenization and Smart Contracts.

Tokenization allows brands to create digital representations of loyalty points, rewards, or exclusive experiences as blockchain-based assets. These tokens can be programmed with specific attributes, transfer rules, and expiration conditions, offering unprecedented flexibility in reward design.

Smart contracts, self-executing code on the blockchain, automate the distribution, redemption, and management of loyalty rewards. This automation reduces administrative overhead, ensures transparency, and enables real-time updating of loyalty statuses and rewards.

Unlike traditional siloed programs, loyalty tokens can be designed for cross-platform compatibility. This interoperability allows customers to utilize their rewards across multiple brands or services within a broader ecosystem, significantly enhancing the perceived value of loyalty points. They gain true ownership of their loyalty rewards as digital assets. This ownership extends beyond mere points accumulation, allowing for the transfer, trading, or even selling of rewards, subject to predefined rules encoded in smart contracts.

This ecosystem makes it easier to enable the creation of more immersive and interactive loyalty experiences. Brands can implement gamified elements such as challenges, quests, or exclusive NFT collections, fostering deeper engagement and a sense of community among participants. Some initiatives also incorporate decentralized autonomous organization (DAO) structures, allowing loyal customers to participate in decision-making processes regarding program rules, reward offerings, or even broader brand strategies.

Finally, the on-chain nature of Web3 loyalty programs provides full visibility into the issuance, distribution, and redemption of rewards. This transparency builds trust and allows for more accurate valuation of loyalty programs as corporate assets.

These characteristics offer several distinct advantages over traditional loyalty schemes:

• Enhanced liquidity: tokenized rewards can be more easily exchanged or converted, increasing their perceived value to customers.
• Reduced fraud: immutability and cryptographic security significantly decrease the risk of loyalty point fraud or manipulation.
• Real-time insights: on-chain data provides instant visibility into program performance and customer behavior, enabling agile strategy adjustments.
• Lower operational costs: automation through smart contracts can substantially reduce the administrative burden of managing loyalty programs.

It is important to evoke eventual considerations, as things are not cristal clear and all bright.

The landscape is still evolving, and challenges remain. Regulatory uncertainties loom large, as the tokenization of rewards may intersect with complex financial regulations, requiring careful navigation. The technical complexity of blockchain systems poses a significant hurdle for widespread adoption, potentially alienating less tech-savvy customers and widening the digital divide. Moreover, the volatility inherent in many cryptocurrency markets could impact the stability and perceived value of tokenized rewards, potentially undermining program effectiveness.

As brands explore this new frontier, they must also grapple with integrating these novel systems with existing infrastructure, a process that can be both complex and costly. While the potential benefits of Web3 loyalty programs are substantial, organizations must carefully weigh these considerations, remaining adaptable and vigilant as the technology and its implications continue to unfold.

The renaissance of community and co-creation

I mentioned communities earlier: they too are experiencing a renaissance, as these technologies allow connecting individuals with common interests and aspirations with unprecedented ease, a true tangible value for brands. This shift represents a significant departure from the profit-driven digital marketing strategies of web2, moving towards a model of authentic engagement and collective value creation.

The power of community in web3 extends beyond mere consumer groups; they become active stakeholders in brand ecosystems. According to Jim Dicso, CEO of SundaySky (a platform that allows businesses to create, personalize, and optimize video content at scalea content), community-driven brands can experience up to 5.7 times more customer retention compared to traditional marketing approaches.

At the heart of this transformation lies the concept of co-creation. In Web3, communities are not passive recipients of marketing messages but active participants in value generation. Research from MIT Sloan Management Review indicates that co-creation can lead to a 21% increase in product success rates and a 18% boost in customer satisfaction.

This direct collaboration between brands and communities, facilitated by the technology, not only reduces customer acquisition costs but also strengthens brand-consumer relationships. A study in the Harvard Business Review found that companies employing blockchain-based community engagement strategies saw a 30% reduction in customer churn rates.

Tokenomics, or Token Economics, plays a crucial role in this new paradigm. By leveraging well-designed tokenomics, brands can create incentive structures that align community interests with organizational goals.

In essence, Web3 is redefining the relationship between brands and communities, creating a symbiotic ecosystem where value is co-created and shared. This paradigm shift promises to unlock levels of engagement and loyalty that were previously unattainable, setting the stage for a new era of community-driven innovation and growth.

Practical applications and case studies

Forward-thinking brands are already exploring innovative ways to leverage blockchain and tokenization in their loyalty programs. These pioneering initiatives demonstrate the practical application of the concepts we’ve discussed, offering tangible examples of how Web3 is reshaping customer engagement and brand loyalty.

These early adopters are not just reimagining loyalty programs; they’re creating entirely new ecosystems of value that blur the lines between customers, creators, and brand advocates.

Let’s examine some notable examples:

• Nike’s NFT Program (.SWOOSH): with a strategy aimed at involving the community in co-creating and trading digital collectibles, with royalties redistributed to creators.
• Starbucks’ NFT Program (Odyssey Points): Starbucks Odyssey has generated 172.5k in royalties from its NFTs, with a secondary trading volume of 2.3M. Discontinued.
• AirBaltic, the Latvian airline, has introduced Planies, an NFT collection that serves as a loyalty program.
• Warner Bros is experimenting with programs with NFTs linked to popular movies and TV series. It generated significant buzz and interest with the release of NFT bundles for “The Batman” movie, with 2000 NFTs sold between 30 and 100 dollars in a short time.
• Bleacher Report Rewards (B/R W2E): a tokenized community activation program that elevates the sports viewing experience. Participants can earn tokens by interacting with real-time trivia, which can then be used to access premium content and exclusive events or traded in the Bleacher Report marketplace. This reward model, powered by Web3 technology, uses smart contracts to create and distribute native tokens that can be earned and redeemed, demonstrating the potential for gamification and interaction in loyalty.

While each implementation is unique, they all share common threads of increased transparency, user empowerment, and the creation of digital assets with real-world value.

The future of web loyalty programs

As we’ve explored, the adoption of blockchain-based models and tokenization opens unprecedented avenues for value creation and active consumer participation. Industry experts predict that these Web3 loyalty programs could usher in a new era of democratized engagement, where loyalty evolves from a unidirectional transaction to a dynamic, two-way street.

Looking ahead, we may witness a paradigm shift where loyalty transcends mere transactions (moving away from a purely transactional approach -buy X, get Y points- to a more engaging and interactive model), encompassing digital identity (users can have a persistent, self-sovereign digital identity that they control across multiple platforms, and that include not just transaction history, but also preferences, engagement levels, and contributions to brand communities), shared governance (enabling community members to have a say in decision-making processes), and enhanced user control over personal data.

Despite these challenges, the transition to Web3 invites us to reconsider our relationship with consumers fundamentally. It represents a continuation of the digital transformation sweeping across all sectors, promising to reshape not just loyalty programs but the very nature of customer engagement.

Several thought-provoking questions emerge:

• How will the concept of value evolve in the context of community-based and co-creation loyalty?
• In what ways can decentralization influence the power dynamic between consumers and brands?
• How will marketing strategies adapt to these new forms of loyalty?
• What role will data ownership and privacy play in shaping the future of Web3 loyalty programs?

Personally, I believe that the success of web3 loyalty programs will hinge on their ability to strike a delicate balance between innovation and accessibility. While the technology offers exciting possibilities, brands must ensure that their programs remain inclusive and user-friendly. The true test will be in creating systems that leverage the power of blockchain and tokenization while still resonating with the average consumer.

The most successful Web3 loyalty programs won’t be those with the most advanced technology, but those that manage to create a seamless bridge between the familiar and the revolutionary. They will be the ones that make complex concepts like tokenization and blockchain governance feel as natural and intuitive as collecting points at a coffee shop.

Ultimately, this evolution prompts us to reflect not only on the economic implications but also on the philosophical and social ramifications. It’s clear that the future of customer loyalty will be shaped by those who can navigate the complex interplay between technology, human behavior, and brand value.

The journey ahead is as challenging as it is exciting, and it will undoubtedly redefine the landscape of customer engagement for years to come.

For further inquiries or assistance with Blockchain integration, NFT’s and loyalty programs, feel free to reach out.

---

Notes and further reading

For those interested in delving deeper into the world of Web3 loyalty programs and their implications, here are some valuable resources:

1. Web3 fundamentals:
   • “Web3 Fundamentals” by Ethereum.org
   • “What Is Web3? The Decentralized Internet of the Future Explained” by Nader Dabit
2. Blockchain and loyalty programs:
   • “Building Psychological Attachment, Not Just Ownershi, Into Web3” by Harvard Business Review
   • “Web3 Opens New Paths to Customer Loyalty” by Boston Consulting Group
3. Tokenomics and digital assets:
   • “What is Tokenomics? – Complete Guide for Investors” by TokenMetrics
     https://academy.binance.com/en/articles/a-beginners-guide-to-tokenomics
   • “Digital Assets: The Future of Capital Markets” by World Economic Forum
4. Future trends and predictions:
   • “The Future of Loyalty” by Cognizant
   • “How Web3 CRM is shaping the future of customer experience management” by Power.XYZ